Hollywood star misdiagnosed with MS: how did it happen?
Multiple sclerosis (MS) is one of those health conditions most of us have heard of, but few of us really understand. Christina Applegate has spent the past five years trying to change that. Since her diagnosis in 2021, she’s been candid about living with the disease and has done everything possible to raise awareness.
The Emmy-winning actor, best known for playing Kelly Bundy in Married… with Children and more recently appearing in Netflix’s Dead to Me, even launched MeSsy, a podcast about life with the condition, alongside fellow actor Jamie-Lynn Sigler.
So it’s safe to say her latest announcement came as a shock to fans. On an episode of the podcast that aired on 20 October, the 54-year-old revealed she doesn’t have MS after all.
- TV star diagnosed with oesophagitis – here's what we know about the condition
- The quiet but deadly cancer symptoms doctors warn are often missed
Doctors originally diagnosed her in August 2021 after MRI scans of her brain showed dozens of lesions. She spent years having infusions, until her doctor suddenly paused treatment. When her body did not respond in a way that would indicate she had MS, it was concluded that she did not, in fact, have the autoimmune disease.
‘She came into the room and said, “Congratulations, you don’t have MS”,’ Applegate said on the podcast. Despite the joy with which it was announced, Applegate said she was far from relieved.
She also said her symptoms haven’t gone anywhere, and some have got worse, but she no longer has a name for what’s causing them. She described it as being ‘back at square one’. She added that she felt like she had ‘let everybody down’ by becoming the ‘poster child for MS’.
But in the most recent episode, she made it clear she isn’t walking away. ‘You guys are my people,’ she said. ‘Even though I don't have this disease, I have fallen in love with everyone that we know, our listeners and our friends that have MS, and I'm still your warrior, and I'm still going to speak out on your behalf forever and ever.’
She also said she’s glad her story is raising awareness of misdiagnosis, though she never wanted to cause any hysteria.
As shocking as her story is, it’s a lot more common than most of us would assume. Studies suggest that between 15% and 20% of people diagnosed with MS turn out not to have it. For some, the mistake goes unnoticed for a long time. One study found that a third of patients had lived with the wrong diagnosis for a decade or more.

What is MS?
MS is a lifelong neurological condition that affects the central nervous system, including the brain and spinal cord. In MS, the immune system mistakenly attacks the protective coating around the nerves, which disrupts messages travelling between the brain and the body. That’s why symptoms can be so varied, from fatigue and blurred vision to numbness and problems with balance.
Exactly what triggers it is still something of a mystery, but experts generally agree it comes down to a mix of genetic and environmental factors.
Most people are diagnosed with relapsing-remitting MS, where symptoms flare up then ease or disappear, sometimes for months or even years at a time. In progressive MS, symptoms gradually get worse rather than coming and going.
MS is most commonly diagnosed between the ages of 20 and 40, and women are up to three times more likely to have it than men. An estimated 3.1 million people worldwide are now living with MS, a rise of 54% in just a decade. Part of that rise is due to the fact that doctors have more tools than ever to identify the condition, but that doesn’t make it straightforward.
How it’s diagnosed
What makes MS so easy to misdiagnose is the fact there’s no single test to confirm either way. Instead, neurologists have to build a case from lots of different clues. They’ll ask about a patient's symptoms and medical history before carrying out a physical exam, then use MRI scans to look for damage – lesions – in the brain and spinal cord. Sometimes a lumbar puncture is needed too, where a sample of the fluid around the spine is checked for certain proteins.
All of this is measured against a set of guidelines called the McDonald criteria, which look for signs of damage in parts of the nervous system. Even then, one neurologist publicly said that no single part of the process can confirm MS with ‘100% certainty’.
A big part of the problem is that many of the symptoms crop up in lots of other conditions. The MRI is the most useful tool, but marks resembling MS lesions are also very common in healthy people. Spots in the brain’s white matter can appear for many different reasons, and on a standard scan they can look remarkably similar to MS.
With MRI now commonplace, more of these harmless spots are being picked up, and experts believe this may have pushed up misdiagnosis rates. One study of misdiagnosed patients found that doctors leaning too heavily on scan results, without properly considering the person’s symptoms and medical background, played a part.

What else it could be
If someone has been misdiagnosed with MS, the real cause of their symptoms can be anything from a very common condition to something much rarer. Many of these conditions share symptoms with MS, such as numbness and fatigue, which is why they can be so easy to confuse.
Migraines
Of all the conditions mistaken for MS, migraines come up the most. Alongside headaches, some people get other symptoms during an attack, such as changes to their vision or tingling in their face or hands. These can look a lot like an MS flare-up, and migraines can also show up on brain scans in a similar way to MS. In one study, migraines accounted for 22% of misdiagnoses.
Fibromyalgia
Fibromyalgia is a long-term condition that causes pain all over the body, and it often comes with extreme tiredness. Fatigue is also one of the most common signs of MS, so it’s easy to see how the two can be mixed up.
Functional neurological disorder
Sometimes the nervous system isn’t damaged, but it isn’t working as it should. This is known as functional neurological disorder, and it’s often compared to a software problem rather than a hardware one. The brain and nerves are physically healthy, but the signals between them don’t get through properly. This can cause weakness and numbness, both of which can resemble MS.
NMOSD
Neuromyelitis optica spectrum disorder, or NMOSD, is a rare condition that can easily be mistaken for MS early on. Like MS, it happens when the immune system attacks the body by mistake, and it mainly affects the nerves in the eyes and the spinal cord. The big difference is what the immune system is targeting.
Most people with NMOSD have antibodies that attack a particular protein in the brain and spinal cord, and these can be picked up with a blood test. Some medications used to treat MS may make NMOSD worse, so the right diagnosis is crucial.
Spine and nerve damage
Wear and tear in the spine can put pressure on nerves and cause numbness and weakness. Damage to the nerves in the hands and feet, known as neuropathy, can cause similar symptoms.
Stroke
A stroke happens when the blood supply to part of the brain is cut off, starving it of oxygen. It can cause sudden symptoms such as numbness or weakness, often down one side of the body, along with problems with vision. Some of these can look a lot like an MS flare-up. Strokes can also leave behind small areas of damage in the brain that look similar to MS on a scan. The key difference is that stroke symptoms usually come on very suddenly, in a matter of minutes.
Vitamin B12 deficiency
Vitamin B12 helps keep the nerves healthy, and when levels drop too low, the nerves and spinal cord can start to suffer. This can lead to numbness and pins and needles, often in the hands and feet, as well as problems with balance and walking.
Extreme tiredness is another common sign, and it’s also one of the most common symptoms of MS. Unlike MS, a deficiency can be picked up with a simple blood test, and it’s usually treated with an injection or supplement.
Living with the diagnosis
Being diagnosed with a lifelong condition can reshape someone’s entire life. People often make big decisions about work and family around it, and many find comfort in communities of others living with the same thing. Over time, it can become part of how they see themselves, so being told it was never there can be as hard to accept as the diagnosis itself.
For Applegate, that identity was more public than most. Over five years she became one of the best-known advocates of MS, speaking openly about how it affected her and sharing her experience through her podcast.
Announcing her misdiagnosis, she made it clear it was by no means a relief. Recalling the moment her doctor told her, she said: ‘I was, like, not happy at all. Everybody else was so happy.’ She has also described the lack of answers about her health as ‘unnerving’ and ‘confusing’.
She has lost the explanation for her symptoms without gaining a new one, and far from easing, some of them have got worse. ‘You don’t get misdiagnosed and then all of a sudden I’m better,’ she said on the podcast. Applegate says she’s continuing to seek medical care, but she’s keeping her expectations in check.
For anyone who has been misdiagnosed, the news often means starting again, going back through tests and appointments in search of an answer. Some have already spent a long time being treated for a condition they never had. Being left without a clear explanation for symptoms they still live with can make that limbo even harder to bear.

Symptoms of MS
- Fatigue: An overwhelming exhaustion that a good night’s sleep doesn’t fix. It’s one of the most common symptoms.
- Vision problems: Blurred or double vision is often one of the first signs.
- Numbness and tingling: Often felt as pins and needles in the hands, feet, arms or face.
- Balance and dizziness: Feeling unsteady on your feet or light-headed.
- Muscle stiffness and spasms: Muscles can feel tight or heavy, or jerk without warning.
- Trouble walking: Weak and stiff legs can make getting around harder.
- Brain fog: Struggling to concentrate or find the right word.
- Pain: This ranges from nerve pain, such as burning or stabbing sensations, to aches caused by muscle stiffness.
- Bladder and bowel problems: Needing to go more often or more urgently, or having trouble emptying the bladder.
- Changes in mood: Depression and anxiety are common, partly because of the condition itself and partly because of the challenge of living with it.
- Heat sensitivity: A hot day or a hot bath can temporarily make symptoms worse.
Symptoms vary hugely from person to person, and many of them have other, more common causes. If you’re worried about any of these, speak to your doctor.
Read more:

